Hello dear
Welcome to Coletti's Pizza
Coletti's Pizza, located at 136 E Federal St, Niles, OH, has quickly become a favorite destination for pizza lovers. Known for its exceptional thin crust and quality ingredients, each pie is crafted with care, ensuring a crispy base and flavorful toppings like crispy cupped pepperoni and savory sausage. Customers rave about their signature pepperoni rolls and a variety of toppings that cater to every palate. The welcoming staff, including friendly delivery drivers, enhance the experience, making each visit feel special. With value-packed options that leave patrons satisfied, it's no wonder Coletti's Pizza has earned a devoted following in the community.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Coletti's Pizza
Welcome to the delightful world of Coletti's Pizza, a cherished gem tucked away in Niles, Ohio. Located at 136 E Federal St, this pizza haven has been weaving its magic since its inception. The phone rings with excited orders as locals and visitors alike rave about the taste that keeps them coming back for more. Dial them at +1 330-652-8342 to place your own order and dive into a culinary experience that transcends mere pizza.
Coletti's Pizza is revered not only for the quality of its dishes but also for the heart and soul infused into every pie. Patrons like Pillip Price marvel at the perfectly crafted 16” New York style pizza, garnished with crispy cupped pepperoni, which he describes as “on point." His enthusiasm doesn’t stop there; a half sheet of cheese pizza and a top-notch pepperoni roll were enough to leave him satisfied—and with leftovers for the next day!
Another frequent visitor, Ryan, swears by the thin crust topped with rich bacon and sausage—a signature choice for those who seek bold flavors. Add in the jalapeno poppers, and it's easy to see why Ryan finds himself indulging in Coletti's offerings multiple times a week.
Yet, it’s not just the pizza that captures hearts here. Aaron Torrence falls head over heels for the crunchy crust, likening it to a classic done right. He also gives a nod to the hot sausage sub, which his mom declared as the best she’s ever had. Can you imagine the bliss of savoring such culinary triumphs?
Even the years couldn't diminish Jessica Wallace's infatuation for Coletti's, expressing that after trying it two years ago, it became a weekly ritual. With her favorites like the pepperoni rolls, she endorses the establishment as the best in the area. The warmth of the staff—friendly cooks who deliver patrons' orders with a smile—makes for an inviting atmosphere that enhances the entire dining experience.
Even blissful reviews by Dean illustrate the passion behind each slice at Coletti’s. Describing the pizza as “phenomenal,” he emphasizes that quality ingredients lead to pizzas crafted with undeniable love, making each bite a compelling reason to return.
Whether enjoying pizza right at the restaurant or having it delivered to your doorstep, the love for quality and community shines brightly at Coletti’s Pizza. Experience the flavors, savor the moments, and indulge in quality dishes while sharing smiles and laughter with its lovely staff. The next time you’re in Niles, Ohio, don’t just pass by—swing by Coletti’s and taste the passion for yourself!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Just grabbed a 16” NY with crispy cupped pepperoni. It was on point! A half sheet of cheese pizza that was delicious and a pepperoni roll that was top notch as well! 33 and some change. Not bad at all, and more than enough for us to eat tomorrow as well. ”
“ Thin crust w/ bacon and sausage is my go to at this place! Jalapeno poppers are excellent as well. I order from here 2-3 times a week! ”
“ Excellent pizza! Crust was crispy to the center like its supposed to be! Good sauce pepperoni was great with some crispy! Mom got the hot sausage sub said it was the best she's had yet! Can't believe i waited so long to try this! ”
“ I love this place!!!!! I tried here about 2 years ago and I've been ordering since about once a week. I haven't really hated anything I ordered from here. The pepperoni rolls are my favorite they are amazing best in the area hands down!!!!! Try them for yourself if you don't believe me they aren't even expensive. The people that work here are so awesome the cooks who also answer the phones are amazing. They are friendly and they listen to you and get your order right everytime so thank you to the cooks and Shannon the delivery driver is totally awesome every time she comes to my house and we share a laugh before she leaves she works hard she deserves a nice tip and so does the other delivery driver he is an older gentleman he is very friendly and so sweet and he deserves a tip so TO YOUR DELIVERY DRIVER THEY DESERVE IT!!! JUST SAYING ”
“ Phenomenal Pizza! This dude puts his heart into his craft and it shows in every bite! Quality ingredients lead to quality pizza. Once I start eating it, I feel it becomes harder to stop with each piece. I cant say that very often but this is true here. ”
“ Better Food and Pizza than most other pizza Joints. The 16 inch thin pepperoni is 5 star in my opinion. Trust me you wont be disappointed. Only thing is, if you go thru the drivethru, its kinda confusing. You really gotta look for the entrance for the drivethru in the back of the building. Its on the road for the Football Stadium. Right across the street from the parking lot. ”
“ Only giving five stars because ten is not an option!! they know me by name there and everyone is always so nice! Not to mention they have the best pepperoni rolls in Ohio hands down, paired with the amazing sauce and great prices. I can't wait to get home and eat! ”
“ Ever since they have opened, our family prefers ordering Coletti's. We always order half sheets. 1 pepperoni and the other bacon onion and pineapple. The sauce is amazing. And they never skimp on the cheese like other places. The family is very nice. And the prices are cheap too. 5 stars. I'd give 10 if I could. ”